While Final Girl is a worthy blog and one that has been around a while I have to be honest I do not know anything about the other two. I checked them out since the names seem to popping up all over awards recently, DBH even being nominated for a Rondo, and was surprised about something both blogs have in common.
Neither blog is older than Oct of 2009. The archives for DBH go back to Nov of 2009 and the archives for FOTD go back to Oct of 2009. I did notice here that both blogs spiked to about 10% right before voting closed what ever that implies. They are not necessarily horrible blogs but far, far, far from the best on this list, and some great blogs never even made it here. Personally I see these awards as most likely manipulated by shenanigans any more and agree with some other bloggers I have read recently that it may be best to discount them entirely. There is no way two blogs no older than Oct of 2009 have earned genuine respect over sites like Vault of Horror, Zombo's Closet, Frankenstenia Lightening Bugg's Lair or Kindertrauma.
Congrats to Stacie Ponder of Final Girl since she genuinely deserves it.