I voted #3. It's unique, creepy, and and eye-catching. #1 looks like a Syfy movie, and #2 looks like any other generic, direct-to-video horror movie. #4 is really good, too, but it looks too much like a Guy Ritchie movie or something from a distance. It's very cool up close, but not as eye-catching to a horror fan if you're just quickly browsing the shelf at the video store.