2012 Horror Draft: Discussion Thread - Mr. Bungle wins!

[Vlad The Impaler]

Originally Posted by rusted31

-3 for Evil Dead, really ?

I'm not the biggest Raimi fan but that film is a landmark for the genre.

Too right.

Originally Posted by Santa Sangre

I just didn't get what you meant. You meant sidereel, right?

BTW, you just scored a solid 17 from me.

[Santa]

Originally Posted by Vlad The Impaler

I just didn't get what you meant.

I meant that Trollock is just a nice term.

Originally Posted by Vlad The Impaler

BTW, you just scored a solid 17 from me.

Thanks for that. But why didn't you score Nosferatu from Herzog? You said once, that this version is superior to the original. Hence, you do have already an opinion.

[Vlad The Impaler]

Originally Posted by Santa Sangre

Thanks for that. But why didn't you score Nosferatu from Herzog? You said once, that this version is superior to the original. Hence, you do have already an opinion.

I honestly remember preferring it much more than the original. However, it has been so damn long since I've seen it. Because the passage of time has become so great, I require another viewing before I can pass final judgement. Therefore, it would be unfair for me to score it.

[Santa]

Originally Posted by Vlad The Impaler

I honestly remember preferring it much more than the original. However, it has been so damn long since I've seen it. Because the passage of time has become so great, I require another viewing before I can pass final judgement. Therefore, it would be unfair for me to score it.

You are too kind, but dude, I need every single point I can get, since my list is heavily infected with deadly H/S.

[Daenerys]

Thanks Dead Breed.....thank you so very much.

[TheReturnOfSarsoor]

Originally Posted by The Dark Enchantress

Thanks Dead Breed.....thank you so very much.

Did he fill you up real good?

[Mr Torrance]

-3 for the evil dead and -2 for Scream
Hilarious,they must be some of the worst horror movie ever made them

[bizarre_eye]

Thanks for the list love everyone. I was honestly expecting my usual quick first round exit and a lot more H/S's, but it's nice to see, that for the most part, people are checking out and enjoying some of my picks.

[DeathbyIggy]

So what time do the next set of matches get posted?

[CountOrlok]

Originally Posted by rusted31

You should've just score it a H/S, because you know, you haven't seen it.

Originally Posted by oxley

This.

If people are obviously voting on something they haven't seen I don't think their vote should be counted.

Who knows what else they are voting on, that they haven't seen? If it's OK to do it for Twilight, it must be OK to do so for other films...

Originally Posted by rusted31

Exactly.

Score the films appropriately and not just on pre conceived notions or opinions or trailers or just because it's vanilla or a remake.

Don't tell me how to vote, my fellow countrymen. I already explained in meticulous detail my voting system. I am voting on the quality of the recommendation, not because of how classic or popular a movie is. So I'm a troll if I don't give Evil Dead an automatic +3 just because it is a classic? Twilight isn't even horror, so of course I would give that a -3. This is a horror draft.

Recommending me a horror film.. one that is underrated or that I didn't know of, will get a positive score from me no matter what. Even if I see it and don't like it. This to me, is what these drafts should be about, finding out about different horror films, not just the classics that everybody knows about. I want to give a chance to more obscure movies.

If that makes me a troll, then what a shitty world this has become. You people don't want to put any effort into anything and just do the same old thing over and over. To hell with that.. and again, stop telling me how to vote.