A Tale of Two Sisters

[mR_BuNgLe]

Originally Posted by Tool Shed

So...before you thought you were checking out a 15 year old?

Wow, that is kinda wierd isn't it? Ah well, I'm in the clear now...

[mR_BuNgLe]

Originally Posted by Paradis v.1

just to balance out the love for this movie i will re-establish my view on this shiat. drawn out

It's perfectly paced.

psychologically improbable

I'll take the psychiatrist from the special feature's word over yours.

ultimately unfulfilling

Great twist, awesome payoff, beautiful film.

[N2NOther]

Originally Posted by Paradis v.1

just to balance out the love for this movie i will re-establish my view on this shiat. drawn out, psychologically improbable, and ultimately unfulfilling

Translation: I had no idea what was going on so I hate it...Where's my Chucky films?...

[Paradis v.1]

haha, ahhh you guys. Beautiful film? a beautiful waste of my time, and i wouldn't trust a thing that quack says on the comentary. They give out P.h.s like condoms at an AIDS walk these days. Of course they're gonna find one that corroborates their chickenscratch screenplay. Honestly though, it was a simple story that wasn't in the least bit horrifying with some neo-J horror cinematography tricks thrown in and few unlikely attempts to scare the audience by adding some VERY improbable moments like the one under the cupboard.
..0h yeah, and i hate chucky

[mR_BuNgLe]

Originally Posted by Paradis v.1

i wouldn't trust a thing that quack says on the comentary. They give out P.h.s like condoms at an AIDS walk these days. Of course they're gonna find one that corroborates their chickenscratch screenplay.

Right so he's a quack. How is it psychologically improbable again?

Honestly though, it was a simple story that wasn't in the least bit horrifying

But fascinating and entertaining.

and few unlikely attempts to scare the audience by adding some VERY improbable moments like the one under the cupboard.

What the fuck is with this improbable bullshit, and when has that ever mattered? It's a movie with ghosts in it for fuck sakes. Parts of it obviously aren't likely to happen, that's why it's a mooovie.

[Paradis v.1]

Originally Posted by mR_BuNgLe

Right so he's a quack. How is it psychologically improbable again?


But fascinating and entertaining.


What the fuck is with this improbable bullshit, and when has that ever mattered? It's a movie with ghosts in it for fuck sakes. Parts of it obviously aren't likely to happen, that's why it's a mooovie.

You really have a problem with me saying the word improbable don't you. This is what i meant. If you're gonna make a thriller, or psychological twist oriented movie, fine, infact great, but movies like this feel like it was forced in a few moments so it could qualify in the horror dept and those moments felt weak and unlikely considering the story and aim of the movie

[relsh]

Originally Posted by Paradis v.1

You really have a problem with me saying the word improbable don't you. This is what i meant. If you're gonna make a thriller, or psychological twist oriented movie, fine, infact great, but movies like this feel like it was forced in a few moments so it could qualify in the horror dept and those moments felt weak and unlikely considering the story and aim of the movie

that's a plausible criticism (though i disagree). some of the "horror moments" are jarring compared to the overall feel of most of the film........but i think they work. they're both "pillow shots" (mood setters) and "embedded artifact" (puzzle pieces).....they're there to "fore-shadow" in a deceptively obvious way (obvious in that you can't miss them...deceptive in that they only hint).....there to establish or strengthen sense of atmosphere and trigger your brain to prepare for/consider potential possibilities, without revealing anything too plot specific too soon. the fact that these "improbable horror elements" are such a juxtaposition to the rest of the film is what makes them interesting and effective........without such emphasis, you'd be content to stick with the twist and not explore any further.

if i'd level any criticism toward the film, it'd be aimed at the VERY ending, which explains away too much of the film and destroys much of the mystery and fun of interpretation(the first time i watched the movie, i missed the very ending....and found it to be a much better experience).

[N2NOther]

Originally Posted by Paradis v.1

You really have a problem with me saying the word improbable don't you. This is what i meant. If you're gonna make a thriller, or psychological twist oriented movie, fine, infact great, but movies like this feel like it was forced in a few moments so it could qualify in the horror dept and those moments felt weak and unlikely considering the story and aim of the movie

Forced and unlikely?...It's a psychological horror movie with elements of the supernatural...Who the fuck are you to say those things are unlikey?...I got advice for you...Stop watching horror movies because 90% of them are highly unlikely...

[mR_BuNgLe]

Originally Posted by Paradis v.1

You really have a problem with me saying the word improbable don't you.

Just when referring to a horror movie, or movies in general, but that's just me.

[Paradis v.1]

Originally Posted by N2NOther

Who the fuck are you to say those things are unlikey.

who the fuck are to say they are?